Monday, 19 September 2011

Review | Among Thieves - Douglas Hulick

For many of us (myself included!), there's one book that we immediately think of when it comes to thieves in fantasy: Lynch's The Lies of Locke Lamora. So Among Thieves draws an obvious comparison - both are set entirely among criminal society, and both feature rather... enterprising protagonists-on-the-run. So the question here will have to be: is Among Thieves as good?

In many ways, yes. But first, let's get to what it's about: the thief. Drothe, by name - a Nose, or gatherer of all-round information, rumours, conspiracies and everything else for an Upright Man: Nicco. And he rapidly gets out of his depth - like in Lies, there's the threat of war as we learn that somebody's plotting a gang conflict in a cordon known as Ten Ways. And with nobody willing to pull out, an Imperial relic missing, and rumours that a Grey Prince - one of the Kin's controlling figures - is in the driving seat, Drothe and his partner, a mercenary by the name of Bronze Degan, have a mess on their hands. In fact, it's much more than that: betrayals, magic (or 'glimmer'), and the history of the empire all play their role.

Drothe's a nice choice of protagonist: he can't be whitewashed, and he's grey at the best of times - and he's also remarkably good at what he does. A mix between a more inquisitive Locke and a sort of lower octane Dresden, in fact! At any rate, though he can't match Dresden himself, he doesn't lack for interest: his next turns never disappoint. Luckily, he's not the only interesting one. He's got a partner...

Degan, a mercenary. Though they don't amuse us as much as, say, the Dresden/anyone duo, or Locke's crew, there are still a few humorous moments: and what we can see of Degan makes him a nice touch. Unfortunately, the rest of the cast don't get their moments yet: nobody stands out as an engaging third or fourth in our character parade.

...Though we can probably let this go - this is a faster, snappier read than most fantasy, and like with the Dresden Files, characterisation of the full cast has to wait!

What about plot? Well, it's... Surprising - I'll say that! Drothe doesn't escape the consequences either (which, as I discussed yesterday, definitely ups the novel). Would I recommend Among Thieves? Yes - it's a small investment for a tightly plotted novel which reads like a younger Butcher writing fantasy crime. This is fantasy with an edge: fast, rapidly escalating, and for once actually makes us sympathise with the betrayer.

And that, people, is a rare thing! :P

You can find Among Thieves on Amazon here:

Read this book, or plan to? Comment and tell me below!


  1. I already had this one on my wishlist so I'd remember to keep an eye out for it (I'm horrible at remembering authors and titles when I'm actually at the bookstore if I don't have my list!)...I'm even more interested to find a copy now!

    I also have Lies of Locke Lamora on my bookcase at the moment, and you just made me even more excited to read that too, lol.

  2. Haha, same - I keep a note of any titles I'm interested in getting... And then forget to bring the note, though. :P (That's the downside)

    Lies of Locke Lamora is fantastic - I'm sure you'll enjoy it! I have to admit, my personal preference is for Lies over Among Thieves, but both are good reads in the subgenre. :) Thieves, conmen... Always fun to read!

  3. I've been seeing this book around - mostly while I kept an eye out for Ancient Blades trilogy book two, Honor among Thieves, which I'm supposed to be reviewing. It's also about a thief, quite morally grey, whose organization also kind of falls on his head and... I disgress.

    What I actually meant to say is, Among Thieves seems to have the feel of good old fantasy but perhaps be better construed than Ancient. I don't know how serious it can be if compared with Dresden, but since in general lines that's a character I love (whenever he's not surrounded by yet another hottie...) I think I should read this one.

    Take all those constant appearances as a signal or something. :)

    Thanks for the great review!

    Ron @ Stories of my life

  4. Well, I don't compare it with Dresden in the sense of the narrative or narration - more in the sense of protagonist stumbling around hopelessly out of his depth on fantasy-caffeine-substitute (some kind of seed here, as I recall), etc. You know, the usual formula.

    I've read the first book of Ancient Blades - enjoyed it, actually! I admit a slight preference for Among Thieves so far, though: I prefer the escalation of conflict in Among Thieves, whereas Ancient Blades goes from a single problem to 'demon might squash/eat the world'. :P

    Heh, constant appearance is welcome with nice remarks like that! :D

  5. Im also a sucker for the thief/spy character in fantasy, and finished this book about a month ago. I thought it had a really strong opening and middle, but the end felt kind of generic and rushed. I also couldn't help but compare Drothe and Degan to Locke and Jean. Other than that this was a good debut and I would gladly read a sequel!

  6. Really? I kind of liked the compromises made, but I suppose they didn't match the created expectations - though I did think what happened to Drothe and Degan was a good addition: as I' fond of saying, consequences are important!

  7. snapbacks wholesale,
    los angeles lakers jerseys,
    babyliss pro,
    ray-ban sunglasses,
    ray ban sunglasses outlet,
    coach outlet online,
    nike air huarache,
    colts jerseys,
    lululemon outlet,
    pandora outlet,
    oakley sunglasses,
    michael kors outlet online,
    nike shoes,
    marc jacobs outlet,
    camisetas futbol baratas,
    oakland raiders jerseys,
    mont blanc pens,
    the north face outlet,
    tommy hilfiger,

  8. ddddd1014ugg boots,
    michael kors outlet store,
    prada outlet,
    supra sneakers
    ugg outlet,
    cheap nfl jerseys,
    adidas outlet store,
    cleveland cavaliers,
    black friday,
    chicago bears,
    nike air max,
    michael kors outlet online,michael kors,kors outlet,michael kors outlet,michael kors handbags,michael kors outlet online sale,michael kors handbags clearance,michael kors purses,,michael kors bags,michael kors shoes,michaelkors,cheap michael kors
    north face jackets,
    los angeles lakers,
    true religion sale,
    ugg outlet store,
    pandora charms,
    abercrombie barcelona,abercrombie spain,hollister spain,abercrombie fitch spain