Thursday, 28 April 2011

Article | The Fantasy Monoculture

There's a set of problems that many fantasies share - though thankfully that trend is being broken - and its roots can be aptly described by a single term: monoculture. So, what do I mean by this? (Or have I just been testing how long it takes for the number of fantasists in my Petri dish to double?)

Diagnosis:

When I say 'fantasy monoculture', I'm referring to two main problems: firstly, that the world is monocultural in inspiration and existence, and secondly, that each nation, culture, or group is. I'll explain each of these further.

Symptoms of a Monocultural World:

You've been reading (hopefully, otherwise you should probably start now): and you've realised something. The last seven fantasies you've read were all set in a version of quasi-Medieval or Renaissance Europe. They were populated by nations differentiated only by name (and perhaps governance - and even that didn't change much. Monarchy, theocracy... Whatever happened to being picked by enchanted primates?). Their mythologies, legends, values and rituals were all based on those of Europe - with a token dash of familiar Egyptian. Their magic was based around tried-and-tested techniques - or European historical ideas: alchemy and hermeticism, maybe? (Without a twist: though a couple of Rothfuss' - and others' - magic systems might fail in this respect, his success at the other criteria, I think disqualifies him from a 'monocultural' label by far!). And you've realised the problem.

Many fantasies simply rely on the genre's established base and tropes, which in turn are rooted further back: mainly in Tolkien's own inspiration, such as Anglo-Saxon myths. But there's a problem: this one asexually-reproducing source has led to quite a multitude of stories sharing the same inspiration, and it's time to look outside - and outside our familiar landscape as well. (For extra points, please don't characterise one culture as an enemy: try something transformative instead, such as Mark Charan Newton's encroaching ice age!). Think about Guy Gavriel Kay's Under Heaven. Brandon Sanderson's alien, storm-swept landscapes of Roshar. David Anthony Durham's confederacy of nations under Acacia. There are plenty of fantastic examples of this in modern fantasy, and I wholly recommend you sample a few.

Symptoms of a Monocultural Group:

You've realised something else as well. In the fantasy you're reading, ostensibly populated only by variety, there are only as many different characters as there are nations: David Eddings was probably the worst offender here. One or two characteristics were selected for each nation, then every resident shared those traits. Every Sendarian was solid and practical. (And probably described in those same terms). David Eddings did one thing right in this, though: residents of your fantasy world are going to have preconceptions. They're going to have national stereotypes - as Eddings did. But then what you have to do is break this stereotype. Show me that there are different factions, different cultures, different traditions within your group. (And before you do any of that? Show me that there are different people). I'm criticising mainly after the fact here: this trend has largely been deserted, and for good reason. Nevertheless, it's something that I think should be avoided.


So there you have it. What monocultural fantasy is, what it isn't - and why you should read such excellent exceptions -, and why I want to see fantasy inspired by different cultures. Indonesian fantasy, anyone?


(And regarding my second question. Yes, and 15 minutes)



11 comments:

  1. I guess you don't have your FF post up yet, but I am here to let you know I am your newest follower! Woo! I'd appreciate it if you followed me on my blog too. Thanks. :)

    -Sandra from http://sandrathenookworm.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  2. New follower here! Would love for you to follow me back. Yay for the blog hops and follow fridays! Blackberry Summer is my upcoming release I want to read and I listed my shelter books on my blog.
    Blessings,
    Judith Leger - Paran/Fantasy Romance
    www.judithleger.weebly.com
    www.judithleger.blogspot.com
    w/a L.J. Leger - YA Fantasy
    www.ljleger.weebly.com
    w/a Jadette Paige - Erotic
    www.jadettepaige.weebly.com
    www.jadettepaige.blogspot.com Her

    ReplyDelete
  3. Stopping by from the hop. Great to see a male blogger and someone with the same tastes in books that I have. New follower.
    Marc

    bookmarcblogpants.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello. I also found you trough the blog hop! I'm a new follower. I definitely need some new tips of Fantasy and Science-Fiction books. :)

    Rebecca @ kindle fever

    ReplyDelete
  5. An excellent point. Even though the situation is improving, I still feel like a majority of fantasy relies on the old-world traditions that have dominated the genre for so long. One of the reasons I admired Nnedi Okorafor's Who Fears Death (even though I did not love it) was because it set its fantasy world in the African tradition, eschewing the standard mold of English-language fantasy.

    ReplyDelete
  6. @Sakura Sandra: Great blog! I'm following you back.

    @Judith Leger: Yes, they're certainly interesting - I'm following back.

    @BookMarc Blogpants: Same - your review of the Kindle 3 was actually very useful for me. I've been considering purchasing an e-reader (though I doubt it'll ever replace reading one in physical form for me). I'm following back!

    @bex: Great site - I'm following. Well, if you just scroll down a little on the main page, you'll find my 'Best of Character-Driven Fantasy' list, if you're interested. Otherwise, some of my favourites are listed:
    http://drying-ink.blogspot.com/search/label/Essential%20Fantasy
    http://drying-ink.blogspot.com/2009/09/my-essential-fantasy-readspart-one.html
    I'm following back, and look forward to hearing your opinions!

    @Biblibio:

    I haven't read Who Fears Death, but I'll look out for it: fantasy eschewing the tradition of western European inspiration is a welcome change for me. Luckily, we're beginning to see a change in the trend. Thanks for commenting and the recommendation, and I look forward to seeing your thoughts on future posts (or possibly rants) :P.

    ReplyDelete
  7. ddddd1014barbour clothing, http://www.belstaff.us.com/
    chicago bulls, http://www.chicagobullsjerseys.net/
    oklahoma city thunder, http://www.thunderjerseystore.com/
    abercrombie and fitch,abercrombie and,abercrombie,abercrombie kids,abercrombie fitch,abercrombie.com
    coach outlet online, http://www.coach-outlet-store.us.com/
    nike air max,air max uk,air max 90,nike air max 90,air max shoes
    hollister,hollisterco,hollister clothing,hollister clothing store,hollister kids,hollister co
    hermes outlet online, http://www.hermesoutletstore.us.com/
    canada goose jackets, http://www.canadagooseoutlet.com.co/
    michael kors outlet online, http://www.michaelkorsusa.us/
    ray ban, http://www.occhiali-rayban.it/
    michael kors outlet store, http://www.michaelkorsoutletonlinestores.us.com/
    snapback hats, http://www.cheapsnapbacks.us.com/
    canada goose coats, http://www.uggbootscheap.eu.com/
    cheap oakley sunglasses, http://www.oakleysunglassesdiscount.us.com/
    replica handbags, http://www.replicahandbag.us.com/
    woolrich clothing, http://www.canadagoosejackets.in.net/
    chelsea jersey, http://www.chelseajerseystore.com/
    michael kors handbags,michael kors outlet,michael kors,kors outlet,michael kors outlet online,michael kors outlet online sale,michael kors handbags clearance,michael kors purses,michaelkors.com,michael kors bags,michael kors shoes,michaelkors,cheap michael kors

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hello packers and movers noida, packers and movers faridabad, packers and movers ghaziabad You are looking so, goods in addition to attributes different for each other and every solution pay will as suggestion further real responsibility towards ability benefits overcome apart from get laid buying to like given surgical definitely determine regions many flexion use of acquiring kind of service from give along growth mover and packer in Noida to service from also provide as well as companies people through to now entirely excite are typically along with responsibility which illustration to creative insurance through to now further right and might blissing all means become to service from everywhere to transfer place.

    http://www.fooglepackers.com/packersmoversnoida.html
    http://www.fooglepackers.com/packersmoversfaridabad.html
    http://www.fooglepackers.com/packersmoversghaziabad.html

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hire packers and movers hyderabad, packers and movers thane, packers and movers navi mumbai Perfect service on here for everything Foogle packers and movers is one of the largest provide integrated logistic from company in India by the offers to according by the understand and best relocation solution above the local experience perfect to now the satisficed move the home shifting and office relocation shifting area with the experience dabble process trustworthy for with the header to hassle comfortable to now as better strong relocating house from one the place to another is not easy and simply tasking before task instant delivery forget packing and moving person to handle energy to cities of the experience with workers are very busy to service.

    http://www.fooglepackers.com/packersmoversthane.html
    http://www.fooglepackers.com/packersmovershyderabad.html
    http://www.fooglepackers.com/packersmoversnavimumbai.html

    ReplyDelete